Why Is My Federal Withholding So High?

Why Is My Federal Withholding So High?

 

If you’ve recently taken a look at your paycheck and wondered, “Why is my federal withholding so high?”—you’re not alone. Withholding can sometimes seem unexpectedly large, leaving you with less take-home pay than you anticipated.

While it might feel frustrating, there are several legitimate reasons your employer could be withholding more federal tax than you expected. Through this article, we hope to break down the common causes of high federal withholding, explain how the system works, and above all, to help you understand what you can do to adjust it if necessary.

Understanding Federal Withholding: What Is It?

Federal withholding is the amount of money your employer deducts from your paycheck to cover your estimated federal income tax obligation. This system ensures that you pay your taxes gradually throughout the year, rather than facing a large bill when you file your tax return. The amount withheld depends on several factors, including your income, filing status, the information you provided on your W-4 form, and current tax rates.

The IRS adjusts tax brackets and withholding tables annually to reflect inflation, which means your withholding amount may change from year to year, even if your salary stays the same. Additionally, changes in tax laws, pay raises, or modifications to your W-4 form can cause your withholding to increase unexpectedly.

Common Reasons Your Federal Withholding Might Be High

There are several factors that can lead to higher-than-expected federal withholding. Here are some of the most common causes:

One reason for high federal withholding is inaccurate W-4 information. Your W-4 form determines how much federal tax your employer withholds from your paycheck. If you recently started a new job or updated your W-4, you may have unknowingly entered information that increases your withholding. For example, if you opted for extra withholdings, claimed fewer dependents, or selected “single” as your filing status when you are married, your employer will withhold more.

Higher income can also lead to higher withholding. The more you earn, the higher your tax bracket, which means a larger portion of your income is subject to withholding. If you recently received a raise, bonus, or commission, you may notice a spike in withholding, as these forms of income can be taxed at a higher rate. Bonuses, in particular, are often subject to a flat 22% federal withholding rate, which can significantly reduce your take-home pay.

If you have multiple jobs, you might experience unexpectedly high withholding. When you hold more than one job, both employers withhold taxes based on your individual income from their company, not your total combined income. This can result in over-withholding because the withholding tables do not account for your total earnings. Additionally, if you and your spouse both work, you could face higher withholding due to the combined income pushing you into a higher tax bracket.

Pre-tax benefits or lack thereof can also influence your federal withholding. If you don’t contribute to pre-tax benefits, such as a 401(k) or a health savings account (HSA), you are taxed on a larger portion of your gross pay. On the other hand, contributing to these accounts reduces your taxable income, lowering the amount subject to withholding. If you recently reduced or stopped pre-tax contributions, you may notice an increase in withholding.

Changes in tax brackets or IRS withholding tables can also play a role. For the 2025 tax year, the IRS has slightly adjusted tax brackets to account for inflation. Even small changes in the bracket thresholds can increase withholding, especially if you are on the edge of a higher bracket. Additionally, changes to the standard deduction or withholding tables can alter how much tax is taken from each paycheck, even if your salary hasn’t changed.

How To Check and Adjust Your Federal Withholding

If your federal withholding seems unusually high, the first step is to review your W-4 form. This form tells your employer how much tax to withhold based on your filing status, dependents, and any extra withholding you request. You can ask your employer for a copy of your W-4 or access it through your HR portal.

Next, use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator. The IRS provides an online tool that helps you determine whether you are withholding too much or too little based on your specific financial situation. You’ll need details from your most recent pay stub and your previous year’s tax return. The tool will suggest whether you should adjust your W-4.

If you decide to make changes, you can submit a new W-4 to your employer. To reduce withholding, consider increasing your allowances (if you’re eligible), adding dependents, or selecting “married filing jointly” if applicable. You can also reduce extra withholding amounts if you initially requested them. Conversely, if you want to increase withholding, you can reduce your allowances or request additional withholding.

Another strategy to lower your withholding is to increase pre-tax contributions. Contributing more to your 401(k), HSA, or other pre-tax accounts reduces your taxable income, which lowers the amount subject to withholding. This strategy can also help you save for retirement or healthcare expenses.

When Higher Withholding Can Be Beneficial

Although it can be frustrating to see more taxes taken out of your paycheck, there are situations where higher withholding can work in your favor. If you’ve owed money at tax time in the past, higher withholding reduces the chances of owing a large tax bill when you file your return. It can also help you avoid underpayment penalties, which apply if you don’t pay enough tax throughout the year.

Higher withholding can also lead to a larger refund. While some taxpayers prefer to have less tax withheld throughout the year to maximize their take-home pay, others enjoy receiving a sizable refund after filing their taxes. If you like the idea of a “forced savings” approach, you might choose to keep your withholding high intentionally.

The Final Word on Federal Withholding…

If you’ve been wondering, “Why is my federal withholding so high?” it’s worth taking a closer look at the factors influencing your paycheck. Changes in income, multiple jobs, inaccurate W-4 information, and IRS table adjustments can all cause higher withholding. The good news is that you have the power to review and adjust your withholding if necessary. By staying proactive and using tools like the IRS Withholding Estimator, you can ensure that the right amount is being withheld from your paycheck—giving you more control over your finances throughout the year.

Why Is My Federal Withholding So High?: FAQ

1. Why did my federal withholding suddenly increase after getting a raise?
When you receive a raise, your overall income increases, which may push you into a higher tax bracket. Federal withholding is calculated based on your projected annual income, so a higher salary means more income is subject to higher tax rates. Additionally, if the raise was significant, your employer might adjust your withholding based on new IRS withholding tables, resulting in a higher percentage of tax being taken out. Raises can also reduce the effectiveness of pre-tax benefits. For example, if you contribute a fixed amount to your 401(k) rather than a percentage, your higher salary means a smaller portion of your overall income is shielded from taxes. This could also lead to higher withholding.

2. I have two jobs. Why is my federal withholding so much higher than expected?
Having multiple jobs can easily increase your federal withholding because each employer withholds based on the income you earn from their company alone, not your total combined income. When you combine the income from both jobs, you may end up in a higher tax bracket. However, since neither employer accounts for the other job, they may under-withhold individually. To prevent this, employers often apply higher withholding rates to cover the potential tax shortfall. You can avoid over-withholding by adjusting your W-4 forms at one or both jobs. The IRS Withholding Estimator can help you determine how much tax should be withheld overall.

3. Why is my withholding higher after I updated my W-4 form?
If you recently changed your W-4 form, your withholding could have increased if you selected fewer dependents, changed your filing status, or requested extra withholding. For example, if you marked “single” instead of “married filing jointly,” your employer will withhold at a higher rate. If you left the dependent section blank or reduced the number of dependents, you will also see an increase in withholding. Additionally, if you specified an extra withholding amount, it will be deducted from every paycheck, making your take-home pay smaller.

4. Can higher federal withholding ever be a good thing?
Yes, while higher withholding reduces your take-home pay, it can have some benefits. If you’ve owed money at tax time in the past, increased withholding reduces the risk of owing a large tax bill. It also helps you avoid underpayment penalties, which the IRS can impose if you do not pay enough tax throughout the year. Some people also prefer higher withholding because it can result in a larger tax refund when they file their return. Though this is essentially an interest-free loan to the government, it can be a form of “forced savings” that some taxpayers find helpful.

5. How can I lower my federal withholding if it seems too high?
If your withholding seems too high, you can reduce it by submitting a new W-4 form to your employer. On the W-4, you can claim more dependents or adjust the filing status to reflect your household situation accurately. You can also reduce or remove any extra withholding amounts you may have previously requested. Another way to lower your withholding is by contributing more to pre-tax benefits, such as a 401(k) or a health savings account (HSA). Increasing these contributions lowers your taxable income, which reduces the amount of tax your employer withholds.

6. Do tax law changes affect federal withholding?
Yes, tax law changes can significantly impact federal withholding. The IRS periodically updates tax brackets, withholding tables, and standard deduction amounts to account for inflation. For 2025, the tax brackets have been slightly adjusted upward, which could lead to more or less withholding depending on your income level. Additionally, changes in tax credits or deductions, such as the child tax credit or the standard deduction, can affect your overall tax liability and, therefore, your withholding. If you are unsure how recent changes affect your withholding, it’s a good idea to consult the IRS Withholding Estimator or speak with a tax professional.

---